Collaborative Planning
Topics: Economy, Crime & Safety, Government
Topics: Economy, Crime & Safety, Government
Creating a sustainable future for Northeast Ohio may require collaborative planning to find solutions for the issues and challenges facing all of our communities. There is growing interest in developing practices of collaboration that strengthen the entire region. Some elected officials, planning agencies and business leaders are beginning to look beyond their own municipal and county boundaries to craft solutions to the challenges we all face. Meanwhile, there are those who question the need for “regionalist” solutions. We as citizens should voice our opinions on collaboration, so we can craft solutions that suit all of our needs.
Individual Impact
We live in a region of interconnected communities. We might live in one and work, shop and enjoy recreational amenities in others. In that light, our individual quality of life is connected to the prosperity of all the communities in Northeast Ohio. With increasing costs and diminishing tax revenues some communities in Northeast Ohio are having difficulty maintaining a high level of service for residents. In lieu of tax increases, some communities have looked for other innovative cost savings measures, such as shared purchasing, shared dispatch services and other shared municipal services. These efforts have allowed communities to maintain services without significant tax increases to its residents. Advocates of far-reaching proposals--such as regional land use planning and tax base sharing--say they could help thriving and struggling communities alike. These proposals would affect every community in Northeast Ohio in different ways, but, in theory, would provide benefits to all communities.
Bones of Contention
While talks are in motion locally for collaboration, action is required by the state to make many of these ideas a reality. Municipalities and counties operate through powers granted in the Ohio Constitution and Ohio Revised Code. Currently, the state law does not allow for many of the regional collaboration efforts being put forth. Also, the idea of local tax revenues shared beyond municipal borders is a major sticking point for some local leaders. Also leaders in some currently thriving communities object to both the idea of giving away revenue and allowing other municipalities to have a voice in local planning decisions.
State of the issue
With the current state budget crisis, most communities are taking a “wait and see” stance in terms of their own budgets. Municipalities receive funding directly from the state; however with the impending state deficit this funding will surely be cut. Additionally, the Governor Kasich has proposed eliminating the estate tax in Ohio. Municipalities currently receive 80 percent of the estate tax with the remainder going to the state. The elimination of this tax will create another funding gap, which municpalities will need to fill. The Regional Prosperity Initiative is a regional land use planning and tax revenue sharing proposal for Northeast Ohio. The initiative has the support of local elected officials, but still faces an uphill battle.
Created On: 01/14/2011
It's your Civic Commons, so you get to start the conversation you think is important.
Start a ConversationDan Moulthrop – Radio show airing 2/12/11. Citizens respond to the idea of collaborative planning and resource sharing; Cindy Lombardo on the shared resource that is the library; Lia Lockert brings new voices; Luke on the couch.
Dan Moulthrop – Civic Commons 2/5/2011 radio show focuses on the tax base sharing ideas advocated by Regional Prosperity Initiative. We interview Hudson Mayor Bill Currin and hear from Lakewood resident Don Pawlowski.
Why We Need Collaborative Planning - The Montrose/Wal-Mart example
Jason Segedy – Montrose is the premier retail and shopping destination in Summit County. It is also an important corporate center, containing thousands of high-paying jobs in several large office parks. Thousands of people also live in this area in a mix of single-family and multi-family housing. It is a place in every sense of the word. . .except the governmental sense. For what Akron-area residents call "Montrose" is in fact portions of three local communities: Fairlawn, Copley Township, and Bath Township. What this means is that, in effect, "No one rules the 'wild west' of Montrose". There is no one political or governmental entity in charge of producing a comprehensive land use plan for the entire retail area, ensuring that it is zoned in a consistent manner, or that it follows a unified design standard. Similarly, no one entity is in charge of establishing and implementing a detailed transportation improvement plan for the area. Unsurprisingly, the history of Montrose is one of largely uncoordinated and unplanned development. Numerous disjointed development decisions have resulted in poor access management, poor interconnectivity, and an extremely limited ability for the area to be accessed by public transportation, pedestrians, or cyclists. Tens of millions of public and private dollars have been spent in order to ensure that nearby roadways operate at an adequate level of service. The latest planning challenge to face Montrose is the announcement that the existing Wal-Mart and Sam's Club in Fairlawn may be relocating to a currently undeveloped site in Copley Township, less than one mile away. The land use and transportation impacts of this move are likely to be undesirable to taxpayers, as they may entail a significant expenditure of public funds to address the resulting traffic problems. The issue of uncoordinated land use and infrastructure planning is by no means unique to the Montrose area. It is a situation that has occurred, does occur, and will occur in communities throughout our region. At a time of economic hardship, it is critical that the public sector, the private sector, and everyday people work collaboratively to innovate new ways of planning our communities; ways that are truly sustainable - economically, environmentally, and socially. The following report discusses these particular challenges at greater length.
CSU Presentation - Jason Segedy (Office 2000 compatible).ppt
Jason Segedy – You may be interested in a presentation that I have prepared discussing collaborative regional planning and the soon-to-be-launched Northeast Ohio Sustainable Communities initiative.
Where is the revenue to fix the infrastructure?
Jason Russell – First suburbs are facing increased rehabilitation costs and declining revenues.